An interview with Judge Harvey Brownstone: Advice for Family Lawyers
Josh D. Simon
Family Lawyer Magazine Contributing WriterFamily Lawyer Magazine spoke with Judge Harvey Brownstone, who has been sitting on the family law bench for over a decade, and asked him to share some advice for family lawyers on how they can be more successful and better serve their clients. Judge Brownstone shared six outstanding tips with us.
1: Know and respect your client’s emotional stage.
It’s rare that divorcing spouses are at the same emotional stage. It’s far more common – in fact, it’s the norm with very few exceptions – for one spouse to have emotionally disengaged from the marriage months, or even years before formal divorce proceedings begin.
And while it’s an overstatement to say that even the most emotionally prepared spouse is 100% ready for what the real divorce experience holds in store – with all of its uncertainties, stresses, procedures, complex children’s issues and of course, costs – it’s true that the spouse who initiates the divorce is almost always in much better shape to make key divorce decisions: what to do with the house, how to tie up the loose ends, and so on.
Family lawyers therefore do their client – and themselves, for that matter – an immense service by paying close attention to their client’s emotional stage. Are they emotionally disengaged, and therefore capable of seeing their divorce as a business transaction? Or are they reeling from having the “divorce bomb” dropped on them from above, and can’t separate the emotional issues from the practical ones?
If it’s the latter – and it’s not difficult for a perceptive, attentive family lawyer to quickly evaluate this – then my advice is clear: family lawyers should get their client into heavy duty counseling at the earliest possible opportunity.
Why? Obviously because their client is suffering deeply and perhaps even emotionally shattered, and attending to that serious problem ASAP is why professional counseling exists in the first place. But in addition to that, in the context of the divorce, family lawyers need to equip and empower their clients to separate the emotional issues from the business ones, so they can make wise, long-term decisions now — and not later, after the divorce is finalized, and when it’s too late.
I won’t suggest that counseling during divorce can totally heal clients – for most spouses divorce is traumatic, and it can take years for the healing to completely finish (if ever). But with that being said, counseling helps clients get to a point where they can make objective, well-considered decisions regarding their divorce. And frankly, that’s what clients want, that’s what their children want, that’s what judges want, that’s what family lawyers should want, too.
By Nancy - February 27, 20121 CommentFamily Matters 2011/2012
Episodes 1-5: https://createspace.com/327510
Episodes 6-10: https://createspace.com/327541
Episodes 11-15: https://createspace.com/327542
Category: Episodes
By Nancy - January 25, 2012No CommentsEpisode 115: Fairway Divorce
DVDs of our episodes are now available. This episode can be found at: https://www.createspace.com/327542. In recent years, members of the legal and mental health community have been exploring new ways to assist parents in conflict to resolve disputes in a non-adversarial, cooperative and cost-effective way. In this episode, Justice Brownstone, who has long advocated for keeping parents and children out of family court, will interview Karen Stewart, CEO of Canada?s biggest and most popular dispute resolution company, FAIRWAY, about their unique and innovative process of spousal dispute resolution. Guest: Karen Stewart.
Category: Episodes
By Nancy - December 24, 20111 CommentEpisode 114: Divorce with Dignity
DVDs of our episodes are now available! This episode can be found at: https://www.createspace.com/327542. Have you ever heard of the term ?the divorce from hell?? Probably every marriage breakdown has hellish aspects to it, but everything is relative, even high conflict divorces. In this episode you will meet author Karen Stewart, who emerged from 'divorce hell?' with a mission: to ensure that no one ever makes the same mistakes that she and her ex-husband made. Her book, Clean Break, urges separating couples to learn from her "poor choices and misplaced trust?". In this episode she will explain the pitfalls that so many couples contend with as they navigate the complicated and often frustrating family justice system. Her own experiences form the foundation for the innovative process she founded as CEO of Fairway Divorce Solutions. Guest: Karen Stewart.
Category: Episodes
By Nancy - December 24, 2011No CommentsEpisode 113: Online Security
DVDs of our episodes are now available. This episode can be found at: https://www.createspace.com/327542. In today's world everyone, even children, have daily multiple Internet connectivity, in the form of social networking, banking, shopping and a variety of other transactions. And the experts tell us this is just the beginning of the huge potential that the Internet has to impact the way we live our lives and conduct our businesses. How safe and secure is our confidential information that is stored online? Every once in a while we hear about major corporate databases being hacked, and mass breaches of online security. We are told that identity theft is one of the fastest growing crimes. What can we do to protect ourselves from these risks? Guests: Omar Ha-Redeye, Guy Rosario.
Category: Episodes
By Nancy - December 24, 2011No CommentsEpisode 112: Family Law Access
DVDs of our episodes are now available. This episode can be found at: https://www.createspace.com/327542. One of the most contentious issues that can arise for separated parents in conflict is the question of how to divide a child?s time between parents. Regardless of who has custody, and even in cases of joint or shared custody, the fact remains that a child cannot be in two places at once. Many parents have great difficulty devising a parenting schedule which maximizes the child?s time with each parent, in a way that best meets the parents? schedules and most importantly, the best interests of the child. This can be particularly challenging in cases involving very young infants, or where there is not a strong pre-existing relationship between the parent and child, and in cases where parents do not live close to each other. A complicating factor can also arise where one parent alleges that the other parent poses a risk to the child?s safety and well-being, and is requesting that access be supervised. In this must-see episode, Justice Brownstone and Judge Jane Cartwright of the British Columbia Provincial Court will discuss the legal principles and practical considerations that apply when a court is asked to make decisions about parental access to children. Guest: Judge Jane Cartwright.
Category: Episodes
By Nancy - December 24, 20111 CommentRemarriage after Divorce Episodes | Relationship after Divorce | Family Matters TV
DVDs of our episodes are now available. This episode can be found at: https://www.createspace.com/327542. What are the potential obstacles to achieving a lasting happiness the second ? or third ? time around? What are the pitfalls you should be aware of in creating a blended family? It looked so easy on the Brady Bunch, but our guests are here to tell us that real life can be very different. What are the special needs of people who are contemplating or already in a new relationship, especially if there are children and ex-partners involved in the big picture? Guests: Paula Bisacre, Karina Sacca.
Category: Episodes
By Nancy - December 24, 2011No CommentsDomestic Abuse Episodes | Domestic Violence and Abuse Advice | Family Matters TV
Now available on DVD: https://www.createspace.com/327541. Although this topic only infrequently receives public attention, it is a sad reality of North American life that many homes are fraught with domestic violence. Quite apart from the trauma that this imposes upon victims, it is now well-accepted that when children witness their parents arguing and fighting, this is a form of child abuse. How prevalent is domestic violence? Why does it occur? Can it be prevented and treated? What can be done to insulate children from this situation. How effective are the courts in addressing this serious social issue? Justice Brownstone will address all of these issues in this much-anticipated episode. Guests: Judge Gary Cohen, Carolyn Fast.
Category: Episodes
By Nancy - December 24, 2011No CommentsPets and Divorce Episodes | Pet Family Breakdown Advice | Family Matters TV
DVDs of our episodes are now available. This episode can be found at: https://www.createspace.com/327541. Any pet owner will agree that pets are family too! What happens to pets when family breakdown occurs? What is the best way to keep children and their pets emotionally bonded even if they can?t live together? How do you get pets to become accustomed to living in two (or more) different homes? How do you ensure a harmonious household if new pets (for example, a parent?s new partner?s dog or cat) are introduced into the home? Is it a good idea to give a pet to a child experiencing the angst of parental separation, to help relieve the child?s stress and loneliness? Do pets experience grief and anxiety when a family breaks up? Guests: Rebeka Breder, Dr. Rebecca Ledger.
Category: Episodes
By Nancy - December 24, 2011No CommentsMens Issues in Family Law Episodes | Mens Issues in Family Law Advice | Family Matters TV
Now available on DVD: https://www.createspace.com/327541. In the last half-century, parenting dynamics in many families have changed, as more moms have entered the workforce, requiring more dads to share the parenting duties. In fact, it?s no longer that uncommon to find some families with stay-at-home dads, with moms who are the breadwinners. How has this shifting culture been reflected in parenting arrangements after separation? Courts make custody and access decisions based on the best interests of the child, not the parents. But many people continue to express a very disturbing perception of the law and the justice system, and there?s a lot of advocacy for 50-50 shared parenting. What does the law have to say about that? And what can be done to make mothers and fathers more child-focused in their parenting decisions? Guests: Theo J. Boere, Elisabeth Strain.
Category: Episodes
By Nancy - December 24, 2011No Comments